According to a leading UK development lawyer, approving a Chinese mega-embassy in east London could violate judicial standards if government officials provided Beijing with advance commitments about the project.
Possible Judicial Breaches
If PM Keir Starmer or his administration made promises to the Chinese government, it could represent "real or apparent predetermination" of the development proposal, according to the expert analysis by Lord Banner.
This analysis was requested by a coalition of local inhabitants against the proposed Chinese embassy near Tower Bridge, which has generated fierce opposition due to security, civil liberties and planning concerns.
Government Scrutiny
Ministers now face demands to explain whether they confidentially assured Chinese officials they would progress the proposal after it had stalled under the previous Conservative government.
The Chinese government reapplied for development approval a short time after Labour took power last year, and Leader Xi Jinping mentioned the matter personally with Starmer during their first call in August 2024.
Diplomatic Communications
Starmer allegedly told the Chinese president during the G20 summit in November 2024: "Your government raised the Chinese embassy building in London when we spoke on the telephone. We have since taken action by calling in that application."
Opponents of the planned complex, which would span 20,000 square metres to become the biggest embassy in Europe, are getting ready to seek a judicial review if the approval is authorized.
Mark Nygate, treasurer of the Royal Mint Court Residents Association, confirmed they were gathering funds to contest the approval.
Legal Obligations
The matter is quasi-judicial, meaning the secretary responsible – currently the housing secretary – must make his ruling impartially under the law and with an open mind.
In his analysis, Banner emphasized that "currently there has been no disclosure or formal evidence as to whether any 'promises' have been given" or what the nature of such assurances might be.
Potential Consequences
Nevertheless, he wrote that if the prime minister had made a commitment to Beijing, that "would appear by the reasonable and informed observer to generate a real possibility that the secretary of state had a predetermined position."
He said it was of "vital importance" that any pertinent documentary evidence, including any records indicating that promises were given, must be retained by the government, which would be required to reveal them if a legal challenge occurs.
Diplomatic Tensions
Recently, China voiced "serious worry and deep displeasure" after ministers postponed their decision on the embassy until 10 December.
A spokesperson for the Chinese foreign ministry stated China had acted with "the utmost sincerity and patience" over the matter and the UK should "immediately fulfil its obligations and honour its commitments, otherwise the British side shall bear all consequences."
Government Responses
The Prime Minister's office stated it did not "recognise any claims of commitments or assurances" over the embassy application.
Luke de Pulford, executive director of the International Parliamentary Alliance on China, remarked: "Lord Banner has laid down a marker. If the rumours are demonstrated true and unlawful assurances were given to Beijing, the government could face a devastating judicial review."
Related Events
On Sunday, the government absolutely denied any political interference in the decision to drop charges against two men, including a former parliamentary researcher, alleged of spying for China.
A government representative declared "there had been absolutely no political interference with the evidence provided in this case" and denied reports that the official who drafted the evidence privately acknowledged it was influenced by political considerations.
News outlets indicated that one of the two men charged with espionage was carrying £4,000 in cash when detained by police under terrorism laws after arriving at Heathrow from China in February 2023. Both defendants deny any wrongdoing.
A police spokesperson commented at the time: "A man in his 30s was subject to a stop at Heathrow airport under Schedule 3 of the Counter Terrorism and Border Security Act 2019. He was not arrested and enquiries continued."